So, Zoë lost her first tooth yesterday–during her last week of being 4. While her older brother, who is 6 1/2, waits patiently (okay-so not really all that patiently) to lose his first tooth. When I picked the kids up from school, Zoë had a huge smile and was holding the coveted tooth treasure chest. My heart sunk. Not only did my not quite 5-year-old baby lose her first tooth, but I immediately felt the heartache of my going on 7 son’s despair that he still had not lost his first tooth. A tooth that has been looser longer than that of the not quite 5-year-old.

I tried to play this moment down, which I know isn’t fair to Zoë, but I just couldn’t bear to “rub it in” for Noah that he still has all of his baby teeth. UGH!
I waited until Zoë was done w/gymnastics to talk to her about it–as Noah still had an hour of class left. She was so excited. Turns out she pulled the tooth out herself during nap time. Holy Crap…Seriously? I know this should surprise me as this is the kid who gets shots at the Dr. and doesn’t flinch. At. All. She is daring and fearless. I am certain that when I pick her up today her second tooth will also be secured safely in a another tooth treasure chest. Serving a double dose of despair to her brother as he has to endure the lost teeth and her birthday this weekend. Sucks to be Noah this week.
We talked about her friends and how everyone was excited that Zoë lost a tooth–except for her “boyfriend.” She told him and he said “That’s not very impressive.” It should be noted that the boyfriend is a year older and hasn’t lost any teeth yet either. Then the dreaded topic: The Tooth Fairy.
Clearly, the Tooth Fairy needed to pay a visit. I will admit I was wholly unprepared for this. I was certain I had at least 2 more weeks before I had to really consider this. I started trying to figure out what the Tooth Fairy should leave at our house. Considering that the first visit sets up all future visits. I was warned by many a parent to be careful where I set that bar as they lose teeth for a long time.
So, of course I took to Facebook to see what the going rate is among my friends. I know that at Noah’s school there is quite a bit of Tooth Fairy inflation ($10 for a first tooth). So, I needed to hear from a wider base.
And it turns out a dollar is pretty standard. But I didn’t want to just leave a dollar bill–as that really doesn’t seem all that special. My brother suggested $2 bills–that would have been great if I was thinking ahead. But I wasn’t. I am not a planner in that sense and I certainly wish that I was. So, I settled on gold $1 coins. I wanted to leave 2 since this is the first tooth. So I had to dig through lots and lots of change (an by lots I mean about 30 pounds worth) to find gold $1 coins.
Zoë woke up this morning–hopeful that the tooth fairy left her the tooth (sorry to disappoint–but that isn’t how it works kiddo)–but happy to find to gold coins under her pillow. She showed her brother and he said “She left you chocolate coins?” He was clearly not impressed with the tooth fairy.
“No these are gold DOLLAR coins.”
“Can I have one?” He quickly asked suddenly much more excited that it was real money.
So, while I like the idea of $2 bills–we might be sticking with the gold $1 coins. Although Noah informed me this morning that it was acceptable that Zoë lost a tooth before he did, since he “gets to do everything else first. I get to go camping at school first. I get to be in 3rd grade and be a buddy first. I got to play on the blacktop first. I get to drive first.” I am certain Noah is going to spend the next few weeks doing nothing but wiggling his two loose teeth.