Time For A Revolution

There has been a lot of attention given to the Occupy Wall Street demonstrations.  And I think it is great that we are finally standing up to the big corporations that have gotten us into the current economic crisis.  The companies that have decided that profit at the cost of the citizenry of the US is more important.  But one thing that has been ignored in the conversation, Education. Corporate America needs to be reformed, but so does Education.  I would argue that the real reform of our educational system is a more dire need.  A generation of students (if not more) have already lost their chance–have already lost their future.

Education is a huge part of our countries current issues.  We are graduating more students over all (even though my city currently only graduates 48% of students), but fewer of them can read, write and think critically.  Yet in the name of reform, we turn a blind eye.  I have written a lot about education.  This is certainly not all inclusive of everything I have written about education, but it is a big part of it.  I read this op-ed this morning and it resounded with the what Kelly (aka mochamomma) wrote and Nancy Letts wrote recently.  We know what is needed in education.  We know how important early childhood education is.  We know that students, especially young students learn best through curiosity and inquiry.  We know that students learn by teaching each other and that inquiry leads to increased critical thinking.  We know that writing is a tool for thinking and that students should be writing in every class and reading in every class.  We know that homework should be relevant and not just filler.  We know homework should be meaningful.  We know that standardized test play a role, but aren’t a complete measurement of what students know.  We know that problem solving and collaboration are two of the most important skills students need to be ready for college and the workforce, yet our schools focus on skill and drill activities that students do alone for the purpose of filling in a bubble on a test.

Many urban and under-performing schools purchase canned curriculum that tests students every six weeks and offers pacing guides that tell teachers where they need to be–taking the art out of teaching; taking the choice out of teaching.  I would have withered as a public school teacher under these circumstances.  I left the classroom after NCLB, but before the huge accountability push of testing.  I was a great teacher.  I was the kind of teacher I want my students to have.  I knew other great teachers, who knew their students, who knew what their students needed and how students learned.  I worked hard to make sure that my students were getting what they needed and were learning. I didn’t do test prep with my students and mine always scored highest on their standardized tests.  But I can’t take the credit for than anymore than I can take the blame.  A student’s performance on a standardized test is a snapshot of their schooling not one teachers classroom.  I also believe that if we are teaching the way we as trained teachers know we should, then test score are moot.  The problem has become that teachers have lost their autonomy.  Teachers have lost their ability to teach and are not often expected to just deliver the information and move students through the pacing guide decided for them from an outside corporation who doesn’t know the students are even the school.  This is a huge issue.

Teachers need to push back.  Teachers need to take back education.  Teachers need to take back the curriculum and make it theirs and their students’.

Parents need to demand funding for early childhood education.  Parents need to demand early childhood education that isn’t about worksheets and tests.  Parents need to demand that schools do better.  We need to demand that schools do better.  Our students deserve the best education possible.  I want to be able to send my kids to public school in my urban district and know they are getting the best education.  A quality education.  An education that will push them to grow and learn.  An education that will challenge them.  An education that demands that they think and problem solve.  An education that demands they investigate and ask questions.  Right now…I can only buy this type of education for my kids and that isn’t fair to the kids whose parents can’t pay.

We have a hierarchical educational system, as a teacher and educational researcher, I have always believed this.  We have schools that create and educate leaders and schools that create and educate workers.  That isn’t right.  We should have one system that educates everyone to their potential.

I think about an article I read about those is power who were poor students and got poor grades in school.  Yet they are leaders because of where they went to school, not because of what they learned.  Students who go to urban public schools shouldn’t be relegated to the second class.  Yet they are.  It’s wrong and it’s time we took a stand.

Why can’t Bill Gates and the other corporate philanthropists look at what works?  They could easily fund early childhood education for all with the money they are spending on charter schools and other reform initiatives that are really just about testing.   If they really wanted to make a difference they would invest money in colleges of education to allow for more teacher residency programs (programs the mirror the residency programs for doctors).  If they really wanted to make a difference they would ask educators what works.

It’s time for a revolution.  It’s time for change.  Our children deserve it.  Our children need it.

Sometimes The Answers Are Easier Than We Imagine

We often make things more complex than they need to be.  Take this whole problem we have of education.  I am certainly not making light of the problems in education but so little of the talk has been centered around the kids and around what the REAL problems are and instead focus on those things that seem fixable or at least blameable (parents and teachers mostly, but even students).  Or on problems that are so big and monumental it allows us an easy excuse: poverty.

I have long felt that one of our biggest problems in education, aside from the fact that we still ascribe to pedagogies and philosophies that are over a century old, is one of expectations.  I have been working in schools and education for over 10 years now and I see it so clearly.  Maybe my varied experiences have given me a needed glimpse into education as a larger thing as opposed to just being in one school and teaching in one classroom.  I have always believed and subscribed to the belief that students will rise and fall with teacher, school, societal expectations.  As a teacher, I have always had high expectations.  I gave homework, regardless of whether kids would do it.  I assigned hard reading, regardless of whether kids would do it.  It was hard and frustrating in the beginning, but once the students realized that they were going to have to work, they did and they learned and they were thankful.  I still have thank you notes from students who were thankful that I believed in them and their ability.

I have been in schools where homework is not given because “they won’t do it” or “they can’t do it” or “they have too much going on in their life to be expected to do it.”  These excuses are lazy.  These excuses allow everyone to just get by.  Kids don’t want to Fail.  Kids know and understand the importance of school.  But if schools continually fail them and fall victim to the excuses that society has generate to explain away the often poor achievement of minority students.

I was listening to Radio Times this morning on NPR and Angel Harris was on.  Angel Harris is awesome and thoughtful and smart.  His new book is one that examines what goes into the racial achievement gap.  I know that for some this categorizing of achievement through the lens of race is problematic.  I also think it simplifies things and is quite ambiguous, but that does not change that fact that white students out achieve our black and latino students.  One of the things that Harris mention really spoke to me and is something we really need to examine, “if the system is successful with some students but not others, then the system is biased towards those who are achieving.”  This is so simple and so true.

What is also then obvious, standardized testing is not going to fix the inherent, systemic bias in our systems and the rhetoric of education that has kept the status quo of low expectations.  We need more talk about how to fix the system and really fix it, not just assess it more when we already know what the system is doing isn’t working for a huge proportion of our student body.

All kids want to learn.  We need to start teaching all of them.